The eleven men who participated in the robbery reportedly received shares of approximately $100,000 each after the split, according to one source. If accurate, that figure represents each man’s return from an operation that had taken two years to plan and that would dominate FBI investigative resources for six more years. For a career criminal in 1950, $100,000 was life-changing money. For several of them, by the time the case was resolved, it was also money that had been spent, taken by others, or never received.

—

## The FBI’s Investment

The Great Brink’s Robbery became, within the FBI’s institutional history, a case study in the limits of physical evidence investigation and in the role that informant-based intelligence played in eventually breaking the case.

The bureau had identified the principal suspects relatively early. The investigative challenge was not figuring out who had done the job — it was building a case that would actually support prosecution. The physical evidence was minimal: a cap, some rope, and tape. The money was untraceable. The crew maintained silence. The traditional tools of financial investigation — following the money, identifying unusual spending — were stymied by the low denominations of the cash and the crew’s discipline.

The FBI’s approach evolved into a strategy of maintaining sustained pressure on the periphery of the crew — pursuing the gang members for other crimes, applying tax investigations to their financial activity, keeping them in legal jeopardy — while waiting for the internal dynamics of the crew to create an opportunity. The Pennsylvania arrests of O’Keefe and Gusciora in June 1950 were not related to the Brink’s investigation, but they put two crew members in custody and created the conditions under which their financial arrangements with the other crew members would become unstable.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.