The FBI’s investigation had contributed to creating those circumstances. The Pennsylvania arrests had led to the financial disputes that embittered O’Keefe. The tax investigation of Maffie had further complicated the internal finances of the group. The sustained investigative pressure had maintained a climate in which crew members were repeatedly confronted with the ongoing consequences of the robbery.

None of that determines or explains O’Keefe’s specific decision on January 6, 1956. The decision to talk was his, and it was not compelled by any immediate legal requirement or threat that is documented in public sources. What can be said is that the conditions for his cooperation had been building for years, and that the FBI’s cultivation of its relationship with O’Keefe during his various periods of incarceration and legal difficulty was specifically aimed at reaching this point.

—

## What “Perfect” Actually Means

In the immediate aftermath of the robbery, the press and the public reached quickly for a particular description: the perfect crime. The phrase attached to the case and remained with it through the subsequent investigation and resolution.

What made the January 17, 1950 robbery “perfect” in the sense commentators meant was the combination of careful preparation and disciplined execution that left investigators almost nothing to work with. The physical evidence was minimal. The cash was untraceable. The crew maintained silence. The suspects had alibis or were simply unplaceable at the scene. For years, the investigation advanced almost not at all.

But “perfect” as applied to the robbery’s planning and execution was always a different question from whether the crime itself would remain unsolved. The planning was thorough. The execution was efficient. The operational security was maintained far better and far longer than most comparable criminal enterprises could manage.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.