The subsequent investigation of the crew members unfolded almost entirely within the geography of Boston’s urban neighborhoods. O’Keefe’s kidnapping of Costa happened in this world. Burke’s shooting of O’Keefe happened in a Dorchester housing project. Faherty and Richardson, when they were finally captured four months after the initial arrests, were found in Dorchester — the neighborhood they had grown up in. The crime and its aftermath were products of a specific urban social world, and that world’s constraints shaped every aspect of what happened.

—

## The Role of the FBI in 1950: Context and Capability

Understanding how the FBI approached the Brink’s investigation requires some context about the bureau’s character and capabilities in 1950.

J. Edgar Hoover had led the FBI since 1935 and had built it into a genuinely powerful investigative agency with resources and reach that no other American law enforcement body could match. The bureau had distinguished itself in the 1930s through its pursuit of high-profile criminals — John Dillinger, Bonnie and Clyde, Pretty Boy Floyd — cases that generated enormous public attention and established the FBI’s reputation for effectiveness. By 1950, the bureau was at the height of its institutional prestige.

Hoover was acutely sensitive to that reputation, and cases that the FBI failed to resolve were embarrassments he took personally. The Brink’s robbery was the kind of case — massive, public, apparently insoluble — that could either enhance or damage the bureau’s standing depending on how it was handled. Hoover’s personal involvement in the case, reflected in the bureau’s sustained commitment of resources over six years, is consistent with his general approach to high-visibility cases.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.