—
## Tax Investigations as an Investigative Tool
The income tax conviction of Adolph Maffie — nine months for tax evasion — was an application of an investigative strategy that law enforcement had used against organized crime since the 1930s, when it had been successfully employed to convict Al Capone.
The theory was straightforward: criminals who could not be convicted of their primary criminal activity because the evidence was insufficient or because witnesses would not testify could sometimes be convicted of tax offenses. Criminal income was taxable income. A person who reported no income while living at a standard that required income, or who reported income inconsistent with their observed lifestyle, was potentially committing tax evasion.
For the Brink’s crew, the challenge was that the agreement not to spend the money for six years meant that most of the crew members were not displaying sudden new wealth in ways that would create obvious tax discrepancies. They were living more or less as they had before. This made tax investigation less immediately productive than it might have been with a less disciplined group.
Maffie’s conviction suggests that his financial activity was observable enough to support a tax case despite the general agreement to maintain normal appearances. The nine-month sentence reflects the nature of the tax offense — it was a lesser charge compared to the robbery itself — but the conviction served a secondary investigative purpose: it increased the pressure on the crew and signaled that federal investigators were looking closely at their finances.
The FBI’s sustained use of tax investigation as a pressure tool, combined with its cultivation of potential informants within the criminal community, reflected a strategy that was explicitly designed for the long game. The bureau could not break the case quickly, and it knew it. The strategy was to keep the pressure on, narrow the options available to the crew members, and wait for the internal dynamics of the conspiracy to create an opening.
