The failure to actually kill O’Keefe — Burke’s thirty-five-minute chase through Dorchester, the shots in the leg rather than a clean elimination — changed the trajectory of the entire case. Had Burke succeeded, O’Keefe’s potential cooperation would have been permanently foreclosed. The statute of limitations would have run its course. The crew might have achieved its goal of permanent immunity.
Burke’s failure to confirm O’Keefe’s death before leaving the scene — his assumption that O’Keefe was mortally wounded rather than waiting to confirm the outcome — was the specific lapse that allowed O’Keefe to survive, file his complaint, and eventually reach the January 1956 decision to cooperate.
—
## The FBI’s Approach to O’Keefe: Cultivation Over Years
The FBI’s eventual success in obtaining O’Keefe’s cooperation was not the result of a sudden breakthrough or a confrontation. It was the product of a years-long process of maintaining contact with O’Keefe during his various periods of incarceration and legal difficulty.
The bureau had been in contact with O’Keefe from early in its investigation. He and Gusciora had been interviewed in Pennsylvania after their June 1950 arrests. Both had denied involvement in the Brink’s robbery. The interview produced nothing immediately useful, but it established the relationship between O’Keefe and the FBI agents working the case.
Throughout his incarceration, O’Keefe had periodic contact with bureau agents. The specifics of those contacts — what was discussed, what was offered or implied, what O’Keefe said — are not fully documented in publicly available accounts. What is clear is that the FBI did not abandon the relationship, and that by the time O’Keefe was in the hospital recovering from Burke’s assault, the groundwork for a cooperation agreement had been substantially laid.
