The challenges were also real. O’Keefe was himself a convicted criminal who had committed the crime he was testifying about. His cooperation carried a benefit — a reduced sentence — that defense attorneys would argue compromised his credibility. The argument that O’Keefe was tailoring his testimony to serve his own interests, while testifying against men he had grievances against, was a legitimate one that the defense could and did make.
The physical evidence from the robbery itself was limited: a cap, rope, and tape, none of which could be directly connected to specific defendants. The getaway truck had been destroyed. The money was largely gone. The case rested primarily on O’Keefe’s testimony.
Prosecutors could also draw on the circumstantial record of the investigation — the documented suspicious activities of the defendants, the connections between them and each other, the financial investigations, the tax conviction — to corroborate elements of O’Keefe’s account. But the corroborating evidence did not independently establish the defendants’ participation in the robbery; it established their proximity to the criminal world and to each other.
The jury deliberated for approximately three and a half hours before returning guilty verdicts on all eight defendants. The relatively short deliberation suggests that the jury found the prosecution’s case convincing, most likely on the strength of O’Keefe’s testimony. Eight life sentences were imposed — the maximum available under Massachusetts law.
—
## Life Sentences and Paroles: The Human Aftermath
The eight life sentences handed down in the fall of 1956 marked the legal conclusion of the case but not the human one. The men who were sentenced to life in prison for the Brink’s robbery were not, by the standards of the time, necessarily going to die in prison. Massachusetts’ parole system provided for release after a sufficient period, and most of the convicted defendants were eventually paroled.
