For the events directly within O’Keefe’s personal knowledge, his testimony was first-hand evidence of the highest value. He could place specific individuals in specific roles. He could describe the sequence of events inside the building. He could describe the planning meetings, the preparations, the five aborted approaches, and the ultimate execution.

For the financial arrangements afterward — the distribution of shares, the alleged misappropriation by Maffie, the pressure campaign he conducted through letters — O’Keefe’s testimony was again first-hand, but it was also testimony about events that the other defendants would have characterized differently. The financial disputes that embittered O’Keefe and eventually led to his cooperation were precisely the events over which the crew members disagreed most sharply.

For events at which O’Keefe was not present — the specific conversations among other crew members, the decisions made by Pino and McGinnis about how to handle the O’Keefe problem — his testimony was necessarily based on what he had been told, inferred, or concluded. This portion of his account was more vulnerable to challenge.

Defense attorneys argued, as expected, that O’Keefe’s testimony was shaped by his grievances against the defendants, his interest in securing the most favorable treatment possible from prosecutors, and his long-established habits as a career criminal — habits that included, in their characterization, a willingness to say whatever served his interests. The jury, deliberating for approximately three and a half hours, found O’Keefe’s testimony more credible than these challenges. The guilty verdicts on all eight defendants reflected that assessment.

—

## The Money That Was Not Recovered: Accounting for $2.7 Million

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.