The securities and money orders — $1,557,183.83 — were never significantly recovered. These instruments were identifiable: they carried serial numbers, issuing institution information, and other markers that made them dangerous to try to negotiate. The rational response for the crew was to destroy them rather than attempt to use them. If they were destroyed, as seems most likely, the nominal value of that portion of the robbery was simply written off.

The 1956 seizure connected to the Boston contracting company — described in various accounts as producing between $70,000 and $90,000 — appears to represent money that had been held rather than spent, perhaps a portion that McGinnis or another crew member had retained in a relatively accessible form. The seizure of this amount suggests that some of the cash had survived the intervening years without entering circulation.

Whether any significant portion of the Brink’s money survived as intact, hidden cash into the years after the 1956 convictions is unknown. The parole of most crew members by 1971 — the life sentences had not been expected to actually be served for life — raises the theoretical possibility that released crew members had access to stashed funds. No credible evidence for this has emerged in public accounts.

The Minnesota legend — money buried in the hills north of Grand Rapids — does not appear in the contemporaneous record of the case. It seems to be an accretion of the kind that attaches to famous unsolved mysteries, generated by the question that the case’s resolution left unanswered: where did the rest of the money go? The legend provides an answer, but the answer is undocumented.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.