As a cooperating witness, O’Keefe was giving investigators what they needed to prosecute his former partners for a crime he had committed alongside them. The moral complexity of that position is real. He was not cooperating because he had experienced a change of heart about the robbery or about crime. He was cooperating because his circumstances had reached a point where cooperation was more advantageous than continued silence.

The four-year sentence he received — compared to life sentences for the other eight defendants — reflected the value of his cooperation to the prosecution. It was a material inducement offered in exchange for material assistance. The legal system’s willingness to extend that inducement — to offer one member of a criminal conspiracy reduced punishment in exchange for testimony against the others — is itself a contested practice, one that defense attorneys have always challenged and that legal scholars have debated. In the Brink’s case, the practice produced convictions that would otherwise have been impossible.

O’Keefe was released in 1960. He wrote his book with Bob Considine the following year. He lived for some years after the case’s resolution, though the details of his later life are not extensively documented in publicly available accounts.

What he left behind, in addition to his testimony, was an account of the robbery that remains the most direct narrative from anyone who was actually present. Its perspective is his own, with all the limitations that implies. Its value as evidence of what he experienced and understood is real. It is the closest thing to an insider account of the Great Brink’s Robbery that the historical record contains.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.