The case also illustrates the limits of physical evidence investigation when criminals are sophisticated enough to minimize the evidence they leave. The FBI’s forensic capabilities in 1950 were real, and the investigation used them fully. But a cap, some rope, and tape — in the absence of any other physical evidence connecting suspects to the crime — were not going to build a prosecution. The resolution required a human source who had been there.
This lesson — that some cases are only solvable through informant intelligence, and that developing informant relationships is therefore a core investigative function — was reinforced by the Brink’s case and has remained central to law enforcement practice.
—
## The Supporting Cast: Baker, Geagan, Faherty, Richardson, Costa, Banfield
Beyond the central figures of Pino, McGinnis, and O’Keefe, the Brink’s crew included six other men whose specific contributions to the case have received less individual attention in retrospective accounts but who were essential to the operation and to its eventual resolution.
Henry Baker was among the seven who entered the Brink’s building. He was arrested on January 12, 1956, in the initial sweep, and was convicted at trial. He received a life sentence and was eventually paroled.
Michael Geagan, similarly, entered the building and was among the January 12 arrests. His conviction and life sentence followed the same trajectory as Baker’s.
James Faherty and Thomas Richardson were the two crew members who evaded the January 12 sweep and were placed on the Ten Most Wanted list. Their four months as fugitives in Dorchester before their May 16, 1956 capture added a secondary chapter to the case’s investigation. Their eventual location in the neighborhood they had always known — unable or unwilling to leave the world they understood — was consistent with the broader pattern of the case.
