The FBI noted the men it suspected. The list was not a secret among investigators — several of the crew members were known figures in the Boston criminal world, and some had prior records that made them natural subjects of interest. But suspicion and evidence are not the same thing. The crew had maintained operational security throughout the planning and execution, and the silence that followed was equally disciplined.
What could not be predicted was what discipline under financial pressure would look like for eleven men over six years.
—
## The First Crack: Pennsylvania, June 1950
The crew’s agreement to avoid trouble for six years ran into an immediate obstacle with two of its members.
Joseph “Specs” O’Keefe and Stanley Gusciora were arrested in Pennsylvania in June 1950 — approximately five months after the robbery — on charges of burglary unrelated to the Brink’s job. O’Keefe was convicted and sentenced to three years at Bradford County Jail. Gusciora was convicted and received a sentence of five to twenty years at Western State Penitentiary.
Before he went into custody, O’Keefe made arrangements for his share of the Brink’s money. He left it with other crew members for safekeeping while he served his time. The arrangement seemed straightforward: crew members would hold the money, and O’Keefe would collect it when he was out.
From jail, O’Keefe began to hear things that disturbed him. The money was not being kept intact. His share — reportedly held by Adolph Maffie — was being drawn down. When O’Keefe pressed for accounting, he was told that some of the money had been stolen and the rest had gone to his legal defense. The story did not satisfy him. He began writing letters from prison to his former partners, letters that grew increasingly pointed in their demands for money and in their implicit suggestions about what O’Keefe might be willing to do if his demands were not met.
