What made February 4 different from the previous days of the passage was not simply the wind but the sea state. When a gale pushes through a region where the established wind direction conflicts with the incoming system, the seas become confused — waves from two or more directions crossing each other, producing the chaotic, breaking conditions that sailors call a “lumpy” or “confused” sea. These conditions are more demanding than a simple, organized swell from one direction, because the random breaking crests can strike from any angle and because the energy in confused seas is less predictable than the energy in a steady swell.

 

Napoleon Solo was hove-to or running when the collision or failure occurred. The specific details of what Callahan was doing at the moment of the impact are described in his memoir but cannot be independently verified from any source outside the memoir itself. What is consistent across his various accounts — the book, the interviews, the subsequent lectures and articles — is the description of the impact: a sudden, violent strike from the leeward side, a sound he described as thunderous, and the immediate evidence that the hull was taking water.

 

The leeward side is the downwind side of the boat — the side away from the wind, toward which the boat is heeled. If the boat was hove-to in a gale, the leeward side would be the lower side of the hull, partly submerged as the boat heeled in the wind. A strike on the leeward side from a large marine animal — a whale or a large shark, the two candidates Callahan has identified over the years — would be consistent with an animal rising from below and striking the hull on the downward side of a heeled boat.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.