The specific cause of what happened on the night of February 4, 1982, has never been definitively established. Callahan believed, then and later, that something struck the hull of Napoleon Solo — that the collision was with a whale, or possibly a large shark, that came alongside or beneath the boat with sufficient force to open the hull. He described the impact as a deafening bang that came from the leeward side, suggesting a strike from outside rather than a structural failure from within.
The alternative possibility — that the gale conditions alone had caused a structural failure in the hull — cannot be ruled out. Napoleon Solo was a racing boat, built to Mini Transat specifications that prioritized performance over the kind of heavy-construction redundancy that offshore cruising boats typically have. It had already been through a difficult season in the European Mini Transat fleet, where other boats had also suffered damage or sunk. The conditions on February 4 were challenging enough that a catastrophic structural failure was at least plausible.
What is documented is the result: a hole in the hull that could not be repaired, and a boat that was taking on water faster than any amount of bailing could address. Watertight compartments kept Napoleon Solo from sinking outright in the immediate aftermath — the boat swamped and became a floating, waterlogged hulk rather than disappearing beneath the surface at once. This gave Callahan a window to act.
He evacuated into his life raft. The raft was an Avon inflatable six-person model, approximately six feet across — large enough for the purpose it was designed for, but barely large enough to serve as a 76-day dwelling. Callahan was unable to lie fully flat inside it; the dimensions were simply too small for his body extended at full length.
