Rogers recited the song rather than singing it at the Senate hearing — the congressional hearing room was not, by convention, a place for musical performance, and Rogers was not there to perform but to testify. The recitation was itself a choice that said something about the song’s qualities: it held together as language even without its musical setting. The words made the argument complete.

 

After reciting the song, Rogers paused. The hearing room had become, by several accounts and by the evidence of the footage, quieter than it had been before. Something had happened that was not part of the standard congressional hearing experience.

 

Pastore looked up from his notes. He said something to the effect that he could feel it. He asked Rogers how long the program was, and whether Rogers narrated it, and whether the committee could get a copy of it to view.

 

Then he said: “I think it’s wonderful. I think it’s wonderful. Looks like you just earned the $20 million.”

 

—

 

## What Pastore’s Response Meant

 

The specific words Pastore used — “looks like you just earned the $20 million” — have been quoted and requoted in every retelling of the story, and they have been interpreted, with considerable variation, to mean almost everything from a formal commitment of federal funds to a spontaneous expression of personal admiration.

 

The careful reading is the more accurate one. Pastore was the chairman of a subcommittee, not the full Senate, and he was not in a position to personally award or guarantee any particular appropriation. What he was expressing was his own reaction to Rogers’s testimony — a reaction that was clearly genuine and that represented a significant shift from the skeptical impatience with which he had opened the exchange.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.