The specific dynamics of the encounter were not manipulative or theatrical on Rogers’s part. He was not performing for the senator. He was doing what he always did: talking directly and honestly to the person in front of him about what he was actually working on and why he believed it mattered. The sincerity was not a technique; it was simply how Rogers communicated.

 

What the footage also shows is the contrast between Rogers and the standard congressional hearing witness. Congressional witnesses at a subcommittee hearing typically read prepared statements, speak in the passive voice about policy positions and program requirements, cite statistics and precedents, and engage with the committee through a formal vocabulary of institutional representation. Rogers did none of this. He spoke in the first person about his own work. He used the language of feelings and children and trust and caring. He recited a song.

 

The genre-disruption of this — the specific incongruity of this kind of testimony in this kind of setting — was itself part of its effect. Pastore was accustomed to a certain register of communication in his hearing room. Rogers arrived in a completely different register, and the difference was not just stylistic but substantive: the register Rogers brought was the register of genuine human communication, as opposed to the institutional register of congressional testimony.

 

—

 

## After the Hearing: Appropriations and Aftermath

 

The day after the hearing was not, in terms of public broadcasting funding, a day of transformed fortunes. Congressional appropriations processes do not work that way. What happened over the subsequent months and years was a gradual accumulation of political support for the CPB and for public broadcasting more broadly, in which the Rogers testimony was one important element among many.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.