The comparison between Mister Rogers’ Neighborhood and Sesame Street has been made since they were first broadcast in proximity to each other, and it is a comparison that illuminates the genuine diversity of educational philosophy within public children’s television. Rogers’s deliberate slowness versus Sesame Street’s rapid-fire pacing was not simply an aesthetic difference; it reflected different theories of how children learned and what television could most usefully do for them. Neither approach was wrong, and both have been validated by decades of viewer research. What the comparison illustrates is that public broadcasting, even in its children’s programming, was not a monolithic institution with a single educational philosophy.

 

—

 

## The Nixon Years and the Threat to Public Broadcasting

 

The May 1969 Senate hearing was, in retrospect, a relatively manageable moment in the political history of American public broadcasting. The Nixon administration’s 1969 proposal to cut CPB funding in half was a budgetary reduction proposal, not an ideological assault. It was the kind of proposal that gets made in annual appropriations negotiations, and it was successfully countered through the standard political process of testimony, advocacy, and legislative support.

 

What came later was more serious. By 1972, the Nixon administration had developed a consistent and explicit policy of opposition to the kind of national public affairs programming that PBS was producing. The specific targets were programs like Washington Week in Review and programs featuring political commentary and analysis that the administration believed were biased against its interests and policies. Nixon’s Office of Management and Budget, working with the White House communications office, developed a strategy to cut the CPB’s national programming budget while increasing its support for local stations — a strategy designed to prevent the development of a national public broadcasting voice that the administration could not control.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.