Rogers’s claim, in effect, was that children could receive and benefit from something much more demanding and much more respectful. That four-year-olds were capable of engaging with questions about anger and fear and love and loss. That the experience of being spoken to directly by a caring adult, through the medium of television, was not simply a sentimental nicety but a genuine developmental resource. That the investment of real artistic and educational thought in the design of a children’s television program was not wasted on the audience.

 

The radicalism of this position is easier to see when it is stated negatively: Rogers was arguing, implicitly but consistently, that most of what commercial television did for children was not good enough, and that the alternative was not simply the same kind of content without commercials but a fundamentally different approach grounded in the actual developmental needs of children. This was a critique of the commercial model at its root, and it was a critique that the commercial model had no particular interest in accepting.

 

The Senate hearing made this critique concrete and institutional. By appearing before a committee that was deciding the funding of public broadcasting and demonstrating, in six minutes, what that funding made possible, Rogers was making the argument not in the abstract but in the specific form that public media arguments require: show, don’t tell. This is what public television does. This is what it cannot do without federal support. These are the children it serves, and this is what serving them actually looks like.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.