The specific qualities of the exchange that have given it this long afterlife are worth identifying. It was brief — six minutes is not a lot of time for any kind of communication, and it is very little time for a congressional hearing appearance. It was unscripted — Rogers explicitly declined to read his prepared statement and offered instead to talk. It was personal — not personal in the confessional sense, but personal in the sense that Rogers was talking about his own work, in his own voice, with the specific vocabulary and the specific examples that he used in every other context. And it was effective in a way that was observable in real time: a person who had been impatient became patient, a person who had been skeptical became moved, a person who had given every indication of not caring became someone who clearly did care.

 

These are not qualities that belong uniquely to the specific content Rogers brought to the hearing. They are qualities that belong to genuine human communication — to the experience of being in the presence of someone who is actually saying what they mean, who actually believes what they are saying, and who is actually interested in whether the person they are talking to understands. These qualities are rarer in public life than they should be, and their rarity is part of why the Rogers-Pastore footage continues to circulate and continues to move people who watch it.

 

The cultural moment of the footage’s viral circulation — primarily the period around the 2018 documentary and the 2019 feature film — coincided with a specific political context in which these qualities were felt to be in short supply. The hunger for the footage, the tens of millions of views, the repeated sharing across social media platforms, was in part a hunger for evidence that public speech could be this way: that someone could stand in front of a person with institutional power and say something true, without tactical maneuvering, without cynical calculation, without the managed distance of professional communication, and that the truth could be received.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.