By the time most of the BEF reached the beaches at Dunkirk, they had been retreating for two weeks. They had abandoned their vehicles and heavy equipment as the retreat accelerated. Many had not eaten a proper meal in days; water was scarce; sleep was intermittent at best. They arrived at the beaches not as a fighting force preparing for extraction but as an army that had been defeated in the field and was hoping to escape.
The order that the beaches displayed — the queues extending from firm sand into the sea, the lines waiting with discipline for small boats to arrive — has become central to the mythology of Dunkirk. It was not inevitable. An army that had lost its cohesion, whose men had given up on organized behavior, would not have maintained the discipline required for the loading operation to work. The fact that it did maintain that discipline — that men stood in lines for hours or days, waiting their turn, in the face of German air attack and genuine uncertainty about whether rescue would come — reflects something about the training and character of the BEF as a professional force.
There were also soldiers who did not maintain order. There were cases of men attempting to rush boats, of discipline breaking down at particular points, of the extreme stress of the situation expressing itself in ways that required management. These cases are documented in sources from the period and are part of the complete picture of what happened on the beaches. The discipline was not universal or constant; it was an overall tendency that prevailed despite the conditions.
