It was not a victory. The army it rescued had been defeated. The equipment that army had brought to France was left behind. France, within three weeks, would surrender. Britain would spend the summer of 1940 defending itself from air attack without a continental ally and with a ground defense force that was rebuilding from the material devastation of the French campaign.
The small boats — the little ships of the popular imagination — were essential to the evacuation in a specific, defined way. They solved the beach embarkation problem. Without them, the approximately one-third of evacuees who came off the beaches would have been left behind or taken much longer to rescue. Their role was real, their contribution was significant, and the civilian volunteers who sailed their own vessels were doing something genuinely courageous.
They were not the whole story. The East Mole was where the majority of men were loaded. The Royal Navy’s destroyers and minesweepers made the majority of the crossings and paid the majority of the cost in ships lost. The French rearguard held the perimeter. The RAF limited German air effectiveness enough for the operation to continue. Admiral Ramsay organized the logistics that made all of it work.
The complete picture is more complex, more costly, and ultimately more impressive than any single-element narrative. It is the picture of an operation that worked through the combination of professional naval command, improvised solutions to unexpected problems, the courage of both military and civilian participants, and the endurance of the soldiers who waited in the water for the boats to come.
