The original photographs and film footage from Dunkirk — the images of soldiers queueing on the beaches, the ships loading at the mole, the black smoke from the oil fires — are primary evidence of a different kind. They show, within the limits of the available photographic technology and the access that photographers had, what the event looked like. They are not comprehensive; the conditions on the beaches were not conducive to extensive documentation, and the loading at the mole under air attack was not a situation in which photography was easily organized. But the images that exist are genuine visual records of the event, and their distinction from dramatized film matters for how they are read.

 

 

 

## What 338,226 Means

 

The final number of the operation — 338,226 — is not simply a tally. It represents the difference between a British Army that survived and one that did not, between a country that could mount a credible home defense in the summer of 1940 and one that could not, between a war that continued and one that might have ended in negotiated surrender.

 

It was achieved by the destroyers making their fifth crossing under air attack. It was achieved by the naval ratings managing small boats off the beaches in the dark. It was achieved by the civilian skippers who sailed their own vessels across the Channel into the smoke. It was achieved by the French soldiers holding the last section of the perimeter so that the last ships could load. It was achieved by Ramsay’s team at Dover, processing signals through the night and adjusting the fleet’s disposition in real time. It was achieved by the soldiers themselves, standing in waist-deep water in organized queues, waiting with discipline for boats that might or might not come.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.