Whether the theft specifically added value—as Fishler claimed—is a more complex proposition. The theft did not change the comic’s physical condition, its CGC grade, or its status as one of two 9.0 copies of the issue. What it added was a period of absence from the market and a dramatic recovery story. Whether a market premium for the story of the Cage theft and the storage locker recovery is a real phenomenon—whether some portion of the price escalation from $150,000 to $2.16 million reflects the story rather than the underlying appreciation of the market for high-grade Golden Age comics—is difficult to disentangle without comparable sale data from other high-grade copies.
What is clear is that the story has remained attached to the book through subsequent sales. The January 2026 $15 million sale was reported with explicit reference to its history as the Cage copy, the stolen copy, the storage-locker copy. The provenance is the narrative, and the narrative is part of what was sold.
—
THE COMIC AND CAGE’S LATER CAREER
The recovery of Action Comics No. 1 in 2011 coincided with a period of significant financial difficulty for Cage. The IRS issues, the property sales at losses, the series of direct-to-video films he made in the early 2010s to generate income to pay debts—all of this was occurring in the same years as the comic’s recovery and subsequent sale. The $2.16 million from the 2011 auction sale would have been meaningful in that context, though the exact financial accounting of the insurance recovery against the sale proceeds—whether he netted the full $2.16 million or some portion of it after accounting for the earlier insurance payout—is not established in the public record.