## The Testimony That Changed Everything

 

Terry Jo Duperrault was well enough to give investigators her full account by November 20, 1961 — four days after her rescue. The account she gave was consistent and clear: no squall, no broken mast, no fire, the sea was calm, her mother and brother were dead in the main cabin, Harvey had come to her door with what appeared to be a rifle, and she had made it off the sinking boat on her own.

 

The Coast Guard, presented with this account, had a decision to make. Harvey was dead. His account could not be tested further, expanded, or challenged. Terry Jo’s account was the account of an eleven-year-old child who had been through a catastrophic trauma and who had spent three and a half days in the open ocean before being rescued. Her memory, the investigators recognized, would be affected by those circumstances.

 

They accepted her account. The physical evidence was consistent with it, and Harvey’s history was consistent with it. The mast, boat owners and experts noted, was structurally sound and had recently passed inspection. Harold Pegg, the *Bluebelle*’s owner, disputed Harvey’s account of the mast failure on those grounds. The idea that a sudden squall had dismasted the boat, causing a fire that killed five people, was implausible to those who knew the vessel and its condition.

 

Terry Jo underwent a sodium amytal interview — the use of sodium amytal, sometimes called “truth serum,” as a technique for assisting memory retrieval — at some point during the investigation to help her access and trust memories from that night that she found fragmentary or uncertain. The technique was more commonly used in psychiatric and investigative contexts in that era than it is today; its value for recovering accurate memories is contested in modern forensic psychology, but at the time it was considered a reasonable tool for helping trauma survivors organize and trust their recollections. The specific details she provided during and after this process were consistent with her earlier accounts.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.