Whether Harvey was what the Coast Guard concluded he was — a man who killed his wife for insurance money and then killed four witnesses to cover the crime — cannot be established with the certainty of a criminal verdict. He never stood trial. He never had the opportunity to present a defense. The case against him rests on the physical evidence, Terry Jo’s testimony, the circumstantial evidence of his history, and the Coast Guard’s administrative findings. It is a compelling case. It is not a verdict in the legal sense.

 

What can be said with confidence is that Harvey’s account of the *Bluebelle*’s loss was false, and that Terry Jo Duperrault’s account was consistent with the physical evidence and with the broader pattern of Harvey’s behavior. The sea was calm. The mast was intact. There was no fire. And Julian Harvey, in the face of a surviving witness, chose to die rather than answer further questions.

 

 

## Carrying the Story Forward

 

Terry Jo Duperrault was removed from the ocean in critical condition and taken to a Miami hospital. She recovered. The physical recovery, by the standards of trauma medicine in 1961, was remarkable. Her kidneys, which had begun to fail during the drift, returned to normal function. Her sunburn healed. She ate. She gained weight. She went home.

 

Home, however, was no longer the same place. Her parents were dead. Her brother was dead. Her sister was dead. The family in Green Bay — the contact lens optometrist and his wife, the teenager with his whole life ahead of him, the seven-year-old girl — was simply gone. Terry Jo had survived a catastrophe that had eliminated her immediate family and left her, at eleven years old, the sole survivor of an event that the Coast Guard had concluded was a deliberate act of murder.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.