## The Questions That Remain
There are things about the *Bluebelle* case that cannot be answered, now or probably ever.
The most important of these is the precise sequence of events on the night of November 12, 1961. What happened, and in what order, and why? The Coast Guard’s conclusion — that Harvey killed his wife and then the Duperrault family — is supported by the evidence and accepted by most researchers who have examined the case. But the specific mechanics of what happened remain beyond full reconstruction.
Why did Harvey leave Terry Jo alive? She was a witness. She could, and eventually did, contradict his account. He had the opportunity and the apparent means to ensure she did not survive. The Coast Guard, researchers, and journalists have all noted this question without being able to answer it definitively. Some have suggested that Harvey may have believed she would not survive on the float — that in the dark, in the open ocean, an eleven-year-old girl on a small cork float would die before she was found. Others have suggested that Harvey, by the time he reached Terry Jo, had already done what he had set out to do and that something — whatever psychological logic governed his actions — stopped him from going further.
The question of why he spared her cannot be answered. It is one of the permanent mysteries of a case whose central perpetrator died before the full record could be assembled.
What can be said is that his failure to kill her — whatever the reason — meant that his account was tested against reality and found to be false. The calm sea, the intact mast, the blood in the main cabin: these details, given by a traumatized child from a hospital bed in Miami, were the evidence that undid the story of a man who had survived other disasters and emerged from them with his freedom and his insurance money intact.
