## The Sea in November

 

The Northwest Providence Channel, where the *Bluebelle* sank, is a body of water between the northern Bahamas and the Florida coast. It is part of the network of channels and passages that connect the Atlantic Ocean to the Gulf of Mexico through the Bahamian island chain. It is not, in November, a particularly dangerous piece of water — the hurricane season is officially over, the trade winds are established, and the typical conditions are moderate sea states and reliable winds. Sailors know it as a passable if not always comfortable crossing.

 

The conditions on the night of November 12, 1961, were specifically relevant to the *Bluebelle* investigation because Harvey’s account depended on a sudden squall severe enough to dismast a 60-foot ketch. Such squalls do occur in the Bahamas, including in November. They are not impossible. The question is whether one occurred on that specific night in that specific location.

 

The meteorological record for the area on November 12, 1961, is not fully detailed in the public sources available, but the investigation’s conclusion — that Harvey’s account of the squall was false — rested on multiple lines of evidence beyond simply Terry Jo’s testimony. No other vessel in the area reported a squall. No lighthouse in the area reported either a squall or a fire. The sea conditions as described by multiple sources for that night were consistent with the calm that Terry Jo reported, not with the violent weather that Harvey described.

 

A squall severe enough to dismast a vessel is not a subtle event. It is loud, violent, and visible at considerable distance. A fire aboard a vessel at sea produces smoke and light that can be seen and smelled for miles. The absence of any corroborating report of either phenomenon from the region on that night was significant negative evidence.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.