The timing — the specific, immediate connection between the news of Terry Jo’s survival and Harvey’s decision to die — is the strongest evidence in the whole record that he had something to hide and that he knew Terry Jo could reveal it. An innocent man who had genuinely survived a catastrophic accident would have been relieved and glad that another survivor had been found, however complicated the subsequent questions might be. Harvey was neither relieved nor glad. Within hours of the news, he was dead.

 

## The Dinghy and the Body

 

One of the more troubling specific details of Harvey’s actions after the sinking of the *Bluebelle* concerns René Duperrault, the seven-year-old youngest child of the family.

 

When the *Gulf Lion* came alongside Harvey’s dinghy on November 13, Harvey was holding René’s body. He said she was dead. The *Gulf Lion*’s crew did not specifically challenge this; a small child’s body in a dinghy, in the circumstances Harvey had described, was not implausible.

 

The Coast Guard’s investigation concluded that René had most probably drowned — that she had survived the initial events aboard the *Bluebelle* and ended up in the water or in the dinghy with Harvey, but had died before the *Gulf Lion* found them. The specific circumstances of her death — whether she drowned in the water, whether she was in the dinghy when Harvey was pulled from the water, what exactly Harvey’s role in her death was — could not be fully established.

 

The investigation’s report noted that Harvey had likely brought René’s body in the dinghy to make his account more credible: a survivor with a child’s body was a more persuasive image of a bereaved rescuer than a survivor alone. The cold calculation implied by this interpretation — using a dead child’s body as a prop for a false account — is consistent with the broader picture of Harvey that the investigation assembled, but it is also among the most disturbing specific inferences in the case.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.