On Sunday, November 12, Arthur and Harvey made a courtesy visit to the British district commissioner on Great Abaco, a man named Roderick Pinder. Arthur told Pinder that the trip had been wonderful. That evening, back aboard the *Bluebelle*, Mary Dene Harvey prepared dinner: chicken cacciatore and salad. The family ate together. It was the last meal they would share.

 

Terry Jo went to her small cabin at the back of the boat around 9 p.m. Her younger sister René had been on deck with her parents and Brian. The adults talked. The sea was calm. By most accounts, it had been a peaceful evening, the kind of night at anchor that experienced sailors count as one of the rewards of offshore cruising.

 

What happened next is not entirely clear from any single account, and the full truth of events aboard the *Bluebelle* on the night of November 12 into November 13 was obscured, almost completely, by the death of the man who carried out whatever happened. What is known comes from two sources: Julian Harvey’s statement to Coast Guard investigators, which he gave before he knew anyone else had survived; and Terry Jo Duperrault’s account, which she gave to investigators after her rescue, once she was strong enough to speak.

 

The two accounts do not agree.

 

 

## What Harvey Said

 

Julian Harvey told the U.S. Coast Guard that the disaster began around 8:30 p.m. on November 12. He said a sudden squall struck the *Bluebelle* without warning. The squall, he said, dismasted the boat — broke the mainmast — and the falling rigging and spars caused damage to the hull. A fire broke out, apparently from a ruptured gas line or fuel source. The boat began taking on water and was in danger of sinking.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.