What it did not have was a living defendant, a formal evidentiary proceeding with the rules and standards of a criminal court, or the ability to compel testimony from anyone. Harvey was dead. His history could be described but not tested in cross-examination. Terry Jo’s testimony could be evaluated but not subjected to the kind of adversarial scrutiny that a defense attorney in a criminal trial would apply.

 

The board’s findings — that Harvey committed the murders, that his motive was most probably the insurance money, that the squall and fire were fabrications — were stated as conclusions of a Marine Board investigation, not as verdicts in a criminal case. The language of the findings reflects this: the board found that the deaths were “most probably” caused by Harvey’s actions, not that Harvey was proven beyond a reasonable doubt to have committed them.

 

This distinction matters for how the case should be understood. The preponderance of evidence strongly supports the Coast Guard’s conclusions. The circumstantial case is overwhelming. Harvey’s suicide in direct response to learning of Terry Jo’s survival is powerful indirect evidence of consciousness of guilt. But the case was never tested in a court of law, and the full apparatus of criminal justice — discovery, cross-examination, confrontation of witnesses, instructions on reasonable doubt — was never brought to bear.

 

This is not an argument that Harvey was innocent. The evidence that he was responsible for the deaths on the *Bluebelle* is as strong as evidence in an uninvestigated case ever gets. It is, rather, an acknowledgment that the *Bluebelle* case belongs to a category of cases — not uncommon in history — where the person most likely responsible is dead, the surviving witnesses are limited in number and young, and the administrative findings, however carefully reasoned, stand in the place of a verdict that was never rendered.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.