This question — whose account gets believed, and on what basis — is not specific to the *Bluebelle* case. It recurs throughout the history of investigation and testimony, and the *Bluebelle* case is an example where the answer was eventually correct: the physical evidence supported the child’s account, not the veteran’s account, and the investigators followed the evidence.

 

The second question the case poses is about the relationship between administrative findings and criminal accountability. The Coast Guard’s April 1962 report concluded that Harvey committed the murders. But that finding was never tested in a criminal court, never subjected to the full burden of proof that criminal accountability requires, and never rendered as a verdict by a jury. Harvey was identified as a killer by an administrative body but was never convicted as one.

 

For the families involved — for Tere, for whatever family Harvey himself may have had, for anyone else affected — the absence of a criminal verdict is a real absence. The administrative finding is the best available, and it is well-grounded, but it is not the same thing as a verdict. The *Bluebelle* case is an example of the category of cases — common in history, often in maritime and aviation disasters — where the person most likely responsible dies before accountability can be rendered.

 

The third question is about what survivors owe the public record. Tere chose, eventually, to publish her account. That choice was not inevitable; she could have continued the silence she maintained for more than twenty years, and no one could reasonably have faulted her for it. The publication of *Alone* was a gift to the public record — a detailed, careful, firsthand account of events that would otherwise be known only through the Coast Guard’s findings and the contemporaneous press coverage.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.