They are not equivalent sources. The Coast Guard report is an official administrative document based on a formal investigation with access to primary evidence. The memoir is a firsthand account co-authored by the principal survivor and a researcher who spent years examining the case. The press coverage is journalism of the moment, valuable for its contemporaneity and limited by its reliance on what was known and available in 1961 and 1962. The Wikipedia article is a synthesis of secondary sources, useful as an accessible summary and limited by the quality of the sources it synthesizes.
Together, they constitute the record as it currently stands. The record is incomplete in the specific ways that any record of an event whose central perpetrator died before full accountability was possible is incomplete: the inside of Harvey’s mind, the specific sequence of events on the *Bluebelle* on the night of November 12, the exact circumstances of René’s death — these gaps are permanent. The record is also incomplete in the ways that any record of a traumatic event experienced by a child and carried silently for decades is incomplete: Tere’s inner experience of those years, the specific costs of the silence, the precise texture of her recovery.
What the record does contain is enough to understand what happened, why it matters, and what it means. A family from Green Bay, Wisconsin, chartered a boat for a vacation. The man they hired to captain the boat killed them. Their youngest surviving child drifted for 82 hours on a cork float and survived to tell investigators what she had seen. Her testimony overturned the captain’s false account. The captain died by suicide when he learned she had survived. The investigation concluded that he had committed the murders. The color of emergency floats changed. And Tere Duperrault Fassbender lived a full life, eventually gave it a written form, and left behind a record of what she had seen and endured and become.
