But they carry, in the context of what followed them, an enormous weight. They are the last evidence of Arthur Duperrault as a person rather than as a victim: a man on vacation with his family, telling a district commissioner he had just met that the trip had been worth it. The catastrophe was hours away. He was happy.

 

The *Bluebelle* case is, among other things, his story and Jean’s story and Brian’s story and René’s story and Mary Dene Harvey’s story. It is the story of five people who died on a boat in the Bahamas in November 1961, killed by the man they had trusted, and whose deaths were eventually identified as murders because the youngest surviving member of one of those families found a cork float in the dark and held on.

 

Their names were Arthur, Jean, Brian, René, and Mary Dene. They were real people. They had lives before the *Bluebelle*, and those lives deserve to be remembered alongside the disaster that ended them.

 

 

 

## A Final Note on Evidence and Memory

 

The *Bluebelle* case raises a question that any case built substantially on a child’s testimony must raise: how do we weigh the account of a traumatized eleven-year-old against the competing account of an adult who did not survive to be cross-examined?

 

The answer, in the specific circumstances of the *Bluebelle* investigation, was provided by the physical evidence: the absence of fire reports, the absence of storm reports, the structural soundness of the vessel’s mast, the calm weather recorded for that night and that location. Terry Jo’s account was not believed merely because she was a child and Harvey was dead; it was believed because the independent evidence supported it.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.