—

## Contemporaneity: How the Team Established They Lived at the Same Time

One of the challenges in analyzing remains from a cave site is the question of time depth. A cave that was used as a hunting camp over thousands of years might accumulate remains from multiple generations, or even from populations that were separated by centuries. Were the Chagyrskaya individuals part of the same community, or were they separated in time?

The researchers addressed this question through two lines of evidence.

The first was the dating of the deposits themselves. The optical dating and radiocarbon dating of the layers from which the remains were recovered placed them all within the period of approximately 59,000 to 51,000 years ago, with many ages beyond the reliable range of radiocarbon and therefore expressed as minimum ages. The deposit as a whole represents a relatively short geological interval, though it still spans potentially thousands of years.

The second, more direct line of evidence came from mitochondrial heteroplasmies. Within the mitochondrial genome, individuals sometimes carry two slightly different versions of a particular sequence — a heteroplasmy. This arises from random mutation in mitochondrial DNA, which exists in many copies per cell. When a mother passes mitochondrial DNA to her children, she typically passes the heteroplasmy along, but the proportion of the two versions can shift and eventually fix to a single type over successive generations. Empirically, specific heteroplasmies are rarely shared between individuals more than three or four generations apart in a maternal lineage.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.