The Chagyrskaya individuals showed extremely low diversity. The Y-chromosome coalescence time — the estimated time to the most recent common ancestor of all Y chromosomes in the sample — was approximately 446 years. The mitochondrial DNA coalescence time — the estimated time to the most recent common ancestor of all mitochondrial lineages — was approximately 4,348 years. The Y-chromosome coalescence time is strikingly short: it means that all the males in the sample, based on their Y chromosomes, shared a relatively recent common patrilineal ancestor. This is one of the signals that pointed the researchers toward female-biased migration as the dominant pattern of movement between groups.
To translate these diversity measures into an estimated community size, the team built simulation models. They tested different scenarios and ranked them using the Akaike information criterion, a statistical measure of how well a model fits the data relative to its complexity. The best-fitting model involved a community of approximately 20 individuals, with a scenario in which between 60 and 100 percent of females in each generation had migrated into the community from elsewhere. This model fit the data substantially better than alternatives that posited only skewed male reproduction, which required a community of approximately 300 individuals to produce the observed diversity pattern.
The estimate of roughly 10 to 20 individuals — consistent with the best-fitting models — represents a breeding community smaller than any recorded human group. It is comparable to the effective population sizes seen in critically endangered species. The researchers were careful to note that the Altai Mountains are geographically peripheral to the main range of Neanderthal populations in Europe and western Asia, and that the Chagyrskaya community may have been unusually small or isolated compared to Neanderthals elsewhere. The findings from one site in a marginal geographic location cannot be generalized confidently to all Neanderthals.
