This finding adds nuance to the picture of archaic human interaction in the Altai. The presence of both Neanderthals and Denisovans in the same general region does not automatically mean they were in constant contact. The Chagyrskaya evidence suggests that the small community of European-derived Neanderthals who used that cave were relatively isolated — from Denisovans, from the region’s earlier Neanderthal inhabitants, and apparently from other populations in general.

—

## What the Study Could Not Establish

The findings from the 2022 study are substantial, but the limits of what ancient DNA analysis can establish deserve the same attention as the conclusions.

The community size estimate of approximately 10 to 20 individuals is an inference from genetic diversity, not a count of people. It represents the effective breeding population — the number of genetically contributing individuals — which is a statistical construct, not a head count. The actual number of people who used the cave at any one time could have differed from this estimate in either direction.

The contemporaneity evidence — the shared heteroplasmies and the kinship relationships — strongly suggests that at least some subset of the Chagyrskaya individuals lived within a few generations of each other. But it does not establish that the father and daughter died at the same time, that the individuals whose remains are in the cave were all present simultaneously, or that the cave was occupied by a single continuous group rather than by related groups who returned periodically over decades or centuries.

The father-daughter determination is based on the most parsimonious interpretation of converging evidence, not on a single definitive test. The alternative hypotheses — that the two individuals were half-siblings sharing a father, or that the kinship relationship was of some other unusual type — cannot be entirely excluded from the data, but they are substantially less likely than the father-daughter interpretation given the sex determinations and the mitochondrial DNA divergence.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.