For the purposes of the 2022 study, the characterization of Chagyrskaya H as an adolescent female identifies her life stage without requiring a resolved answer to the broader question of Neanderthal life history. The DNA analysis confirmed her sex and her approximate developmental stage relative to the adult individuals in the sample. The relationship it established — to Chagyrskaya D — was between an adult male and a younger female whose developmental stage placed her within what researchers described as adolescence.

The image this creates — a father and his daughter, both present at the same cave site at some point during the period between roughly 59,000 and 51,000 years ago — is specific in a way that generalizations about Neanderthal populations are not. It is not a type specimen or a population average. It is a relationship between two specific individuals.

—

## The Research Team and What They Brought to the Problem

The 2022 Chagyrskaya study was produced by a team of approximately thirty-five researchers, bringing together specialties from ancient DNA extraction and sequencing, population genetics, Paleolithic archaeology, geochronology, and comparative genomics. Understanding what the study required from each of these specialties helps clarify both why the finding was possible in 2022 and why it would not have been possible even a decade earlier.

The core ancient DNA work was conducted primarily at the Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology in Leipzig, Germany — the laboratory that Svante Pääbo built into the global center for ancient hominin genetics. The Leipzig laboratory had developed, over twenty-plus years, the specific protocols for extracting DNA from maximally degraded specimens, the enrichment methods for recovering low-abundance human DNA from specimens dominated by environmental contamination, and the computational infrastructure for analyzing the resulting data. Without this institutional investment, the low-coverage ancient genomes from Chagyrskaya would have been unanalyzable.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.