Whether this constitutes “complex” social organization depends on the definition of complexity. Chimpanzees show female dispersal without displaying the elaborate symbolic social institutions of modern humans. The Chagyrskaya evidence is consistent with a Neanderthal social structure somewhere between great ape and modern human in its organizational sophistication — but the data do not place it precisely on that spectrum.

—

## Future Research Directions

The Chagyrskaya study was explicit about what additional work would be needed to test and extend its findings.

The most direct extension would be more Neanderthal community-level analyses from other sites. If additional Neanderthal sites yielded multiple individuals with sufficient coverage for kinship analysis, it would be possible to compare community structures across the Neanderthal range — asking whether the small group size and female exogamy found at Chagyrskaya were characteristic of Neanderthals in Europe and western Asia as well as in the peripheral Altai region. Without such comparative data, the Chagyrskaya findings remain a sample of one.

Additional genetic analysis of the remaining Chagyrskaya specimens — the more than 80 fragments already recovered — could expand the family picture significantly. As noted by Laurits Skov in public comments on the study, the mother of Chagyrskaya H is likely among the unanalyzed specimens if she was present at the cave. The discovery of a second-degree or first-degree relative for Chagyrskaya A might narrow down the possible relationships in the second kinship pair. The analysis of additional specimens could also confirm or refine the contemporaneity estimates and add more data points to the community size modeling.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.