For Chagyrskaya D and Chagyrskaya H, the p0 value placed them clearly in the first-degree category — consistent with parent-child or full-sibling relationships. This was the first step, and it was unambiguous within the statistical uncertainty of the low-coverage data.
The second step was sex determination. Using the ratio of sequence reads mapping to the X chromosome versus autosomes — a method that works because males have one X and one Y chromosome while females have two X chromosomes — the team established that Chagyrskaya D was male and Chagyrskaya H was female.
The third step was mitochondrial DNA comparison. Mitochondrial DNA is inherited maternally: a child receives their mitochondrial genome from their mother, not their father. If Chagyrskaya D and Chagyrskaya H were related through their mother — if the relationship were mother-child or full siblings sharing the same mother — they should share the same mitochondrial haplotype (or very closely related ones). The analysis found that D and H had different mitochondrial DNA lineages.
This difference is crucial. It rules out all first-degree relationships that require a shared mother: the mother-child relationship is excluded because a mother and child always share the same mitochondrial lineage, and the same-mother full-sibling relationship is excluded because full siblings sharing the same mother inherit the same mitochondrial lineage from her.
What first-degree relationships remain? A parent and child where the shared parent is the father — that is, father-daughter — is consistent with different mitochondrial lineages, because the child would inherit mitochondrial DNA from the mother (not the father), and the father and child may have different maternal lineages. A paternal half-sibling relationship — two individuals who share the same father but have different mothers — is also consistent, as the two individuals would inherit mitochondrial DNA from their respective different mothers.
