The animal bones tell a similar story. The bison and horse remains are dominated by individuals that show the age and sex distributions expected from mass hunting or selective hunting of prime individuals — the kind of patterns that emerge when hunters have enough knowledge of the prey’s behavior to target efficiently. This is consistent with Neanderthal hunters who were familiar with the region and its seasonal patterns, who may have returned to the same cave precisely because they knew the herds moved through the valley at predictable times.
The spatial distribution of artifacts within the cave — which layers contain what kinds of tools, which areas of the cave floor show evidence of particular activities — has been analyzed in published reports from the Russian excavation team. The picture that emerges is of a site used recurrently for hunting-related activities: tool making, butchering, and probably shelter during the hunting episodes. There is no strong evidence for the cave being used as a permanent residence, though the distinction between a seasonal hunting camp and a home base is not always easy to draw from archaeological evidence alone.
What the genetic study adds to this archaeological picture is the identity of the people behind the material record. The tools, the animal bones, the charcoal, the sediment — these are traces of behavior. The DNA is a trace of the people who engaged in that behavior. Combining the two levels of evidence — behavioral traces and biological identity — is what makes the Chagyrskaya study more than a genealogy exercise. It connects specific identified individuals to a specific pattern of land use, subsistence, and material culture.
