—
## A Recapitulation: What the Study Found
For clarity, it is useful to gather the core findings of the 2022 Chagyrskaya study in one place, distinguishing those with strong evidential support from those that are more inferential.
Strongly supported findings: Thirteen individuals — eleven from Chagyrskaya, two from Okladnikov — were identified from bone and tooth fragments. At least seven individuals at Chagyrskaya are distinct from each other. Chagyrskaya D is male and Chagyrskaya H is female. D and H are first-degree relatives with different mitochondrial lineages, most parsimoniously interpreted as father-daughter. Chagyrskaya A is in a second-degree relationship with another Chagyrskaya individual. The mitochondrial lineages of several Chagyrskaya individuals are more similar to each other than their nuclear genomes, consistent with female migration bringing new nuclear diversity while mitochondrial lineages circulate within the community. The Chagyrskaya Neanderthals are genetically closest to European Neanderthals. The final 20,000 years before Chagyrskaya’s occupation showed no Denisovan gene flow. The Chagyrskaya and Okladnikov sediment DNA signatures share more with each other than with more distant populations.
More inferential findings: The effective population size of the community is estimated at roughly 10 to 20 individuals, based on runs of homozygosity and demographic modeling — this is a probabilistic estimate with substantial uncertainty. The pattern of male philopatry and female exogamy is consistent with the data but based on a small number of sex-determined and kin-analyzed individuals. The two Okladnikov individuals were connected to the Chagyrskaya community through the same regional network, but their precise relationship to the Chagyrskaya group is not established from the available data.
