Chagyrskaya D and Chagyrskaya H did not share the same mitochondrial DNA lineage.

This is the key exclusion step. If two individuals share approximately 50 percent of their nuclear genome but have different mitochondrial DNA, the most parsimonious explanation is that the relationship is paternal rather than maternal — a father-daughter or father-son relationship, in which the father’s mitochondrial lineage is irrelevant (men pass mitochondrial DNA to no one). With D being male and H being female, and with different mitochondrial lineages, the father-daughter interpretation was the most strongly supported conclusion.

The team expressed this conclusion as the most plausible of the available first-degree possibilities, not as a certainty arrived at by a single test. The convergence of the genome-wide sharing level, the sex determinations, and the mitochondrial DNA divergence together made the father-daughter interpretation the most defensible reading of the data.

—

## Chagyrskaya D: The Father

The individual designated Chagyrskaya D is known from dental and bone samples. He was determined to be an adult male. Beyond the genetic characterization — his genome, his sex, his relationships — the physical remains do not permit a detailed biographical reconstruction. The researchers made no claims about how he lived, what he ate on specific occasions, what he may have looked like beyond what can be inferred statistically from Neanderthal population characteristics generally, or how he died.

What the genetics established was his relationship structure within the community. He was father to Chagyrskaya H. He also shared a mitochondrial lineage and a mitochondrial heteroplasmy — a specific variant in the mitochondrial genome that is typically present only in closely related individuals over a short number of generations — with Chagyrskaya C and with one or possibly two other Chagyrskaya individuals. Shared heteroplasmies are significant because they are transient: a heteroplasmy present in a maternal lineage typically persists for no more than a few generations before being resolved to a single type. Finding the same heteroplasmy in multiple Chagyrskaya individuals means those individuals shared a relatively recent common ancestor on the maternal line.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.