The stepchildren are the most direct evidence of this. The men who had mothers in the pedigree but biological fathers outside the patriline were buried in the monument as if they were full members of the founding lineage. This means the community treated them as belonging, regardless of — or perhaps without full knowledge of — their actual biological paternity. Social kinship and biological kinship diverged here, and social kinship won.
The unrelated individuals extend this point further. They were included in the monument as community members. Whatever biological test might have been applied to their inclusion — if any was — the result was their presence alongside the biological relatives. The community’s understanding of belonging was broader than the genome.
What this suggests is that the Hazleton North community had a concept of kinship that was organized around biological descent as a primary but not exclusive principle. The patrilineal lineage was the backbone of community membership, but it was not the entire skeleton. There were ways of belonging that did not require biological connection to the founding ancestors, and those ways were honored in death as well as in life.
Whether the community was aware of biological paternity in the modern sense — whether they understood the connection between sexual activity and biological reproduction in a way that would allow them to reason about paternity the way a modern person might — is a question that the evidence cannot answer. Many scholars have noted that the relationship between sex and reproduction requires a specific piece of biological knowledge (that copulation approximately nine months before birth is the cause of the birth) that is not intuitively obvious and that some societies have understood differently. The Hazleton North community’s treatment of the stepchildren may reflect a sophisticated understanding of biological paternity, or a different understanding altogether, or simply a social norm that prioritized the mother’s social affiliation over questions of biological fatherhood.
