Bourdin later gave his own account of why he confessed. He said he had come to believe that people close to Nicholas Barclay already knew he was not the real Nicholas, that the family was going along with the deception because they believed the real Nicholas was dead, and that he feared for his safety. These are Bourdin’s self-reported motivations, offered after the fact, and they cannot be independently verified. What is documented is the outcome: Bourdin disclosed his identity, was taken into federal custody, and the case moved into the criminal justice system.

Beverly Dollarhide’s response to the full revelation, as recorded in news accounts and in the documentary record, was complicated. She said the person in her home had never quite acted like her son. She said she had convinced herself he could be Nicholas. She denied any knowledge that he was an impostor.

—

## Prosecution and Sentencing

Frédéric Bourdin was charged with federal crimes related to the identity fraud. In September 1998, he pleaded guilty in federal court in San Antonio to passport fraud and perjury. He was sentenced to six years in federal prison. That sentence was more than double what the federal sentencing guidelines for those offenses would typically have suggested, an indication of how seriously the court viewed the deception.

The 5th Circuit Court of Appeals, the federal appellate court covering Texas, issued an opinion in the case under docket number 98-51227. The case was argued and decided in the federal system because the core crimes involved federal documents: a United States passport had been fraudulently obtained using false identity documents, and Bourdin had committed perjury in federal proceedings related to his identity and status.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.