On a morning in April 1964, a woman walked through the maternity ward of Michael Reese Hospital in Chicago, introduced herself to a new mother as a nurse, said the doctor needed to examine the baby, and walked out with a newborn in her arms. She was never identified. She was never found. The baby she took — Paul Joseph Fronczak, less than 36 hours old — vanished with her into one of the largest manhunts in Chicago’s history, and was not recovered.
Roughly fifteen months later, a toddler with a black eye was found abandoned in a stroller outside a Newark, New Jersey, shopping area. No one came to claim him. He was placed in foster care. The FBI, running out of possibilities, identified him as the only child they could not definitively rule out as the missing Paul Fronczak. The Fronczaks traveled to New Jersey, saw the boy, and brought him home as their son.
He grew up in a family that loved him, with a name that belonged to someone else, in a story that no one — including him — would fully understand for nearly fifty years. When the truth finally arrived, in 2012, it did not solve a mystery. It opened three.
## Michael Reese Hospital, April 27, 1964
The day before, Dora Fronczak had given birth to her son at Michael Reese Hospital on the South Side of Chicago. The birth was uncomplicated. Chester Fronczak, her husband, was at work at a factory when he was reached with the news. By the morning of April 27, Paul Joseph Fronczak was approximately 36 hours old — a healthy newborn in a hospital ward, the new child of a working-class Chicago family.
