What happened next was brief. A woman in what appeared to be a nurse’s uniform approached Dora Fronczak in the ward, told her the doctor needed to examine the baby, and took Paul from his mother’s arms. She left the ward. She walked out of the hospital. She did not come back.

 

The specific details of how the woman accessed the ward, how she was dressed, and what exactly she said to Dora have been reported with minor variations in different accounts, but the core facts are consistent: she posed as a medical professional, she gave a plausible reason for taking the infant, and Dora — in the entirely reasonable behavior of a new mother in a hospital — trusted her. She had no reason not to.

 

Chester was called away from his factory job to tell his wife that their son was gone.

 

The Chicago Police Department launched an investigation that was described at the time as the largest manhunt in the city’s history up to that point. The search involved approximately 175,000 postal workers carrying flyers, 200 police officers, and Federal Bureau of Investigation agents. That first night, 600 homes in the Chicago area were searched. In the weeks and months that followed, investigators examined approximately 10,000 babies across the country, checking birth records, hospital admissions, and any lead that could place a newborn boy of the right age with the right description.

 

None of the 10,000 babies examined was Paul Fronczak.

 

The woman who had taken him was never identified. She left no fingerprints, no witnesses who could give a detailed description, no trail. The case was open and cold almost simultaneously — open because the child had not been found, cold because the investigation had no productive leads.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.