For more than a year, Paul Joseph Fronczak was simply missing.

 

 

## The Boy in the Stroller

 

On July 2, 1965, police in Newark, New Jersey, responded to a report of an abandoned child. A small boy, approximately 15 months old, had been left in a pushchair — a stroller — outside a shopping area. No adult was with him. No one in the area came forward to claim him.

 

He had a black eye.

 

The Newark Police placed the child in foster care and gave him a temporary name: Scott McKinley. The case was reported to federal authorities, as the cases of unidentified abandoned children routinely were in that era. The FBI, which had been investigating the Fronczak abduction for more than a year without resolution, reviewed the case. The boy’s age was consistent with Paul Fronczak’s age. His physical appearance was not inconsistent with what a child of Chester and Dora Fronczak might look like. He was, investigators concluded, the only child they had been unable to definitively rule out.

 

This was a category — “cannot rule out” — that is significantly different from “identified as.” DNA testing did not exist in a form available for forensic infant identification in 1965. The footprints that hospitals routinely took of newborns at birth — which could have provided a comparison — had not been taken of Paul at Michael Reese Hospital, or had not been preserved in a form usable for identification. Blood typing was available but insufficient to establish parentage with certainty. The tools for establishing with scientific confidence that this specific child was the specific child who had been taken from Michael Reese Hospital in April 1964 simply did not exist.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.