Beverly Dollarhide’s situation became more complicated in the aftermath. Reports in multiple sources indicate she took a polygraph examination related to the case. Some accounts indicate she passed one polygraph. Others indicate she failed a second. Polygraph results are not admissible in court in Texas or in federal proceedings, and their reliability as a measure of truthfulness is disputed among experts. The conflicting polygraph reports were noted but did not lead to criminal proceedings. Beverly was never charged in connection with Nicholas’s disappearance or in connection with the Bourdin fraud.
The question of what Beverly knew and when she knew it has never been legally resolved. Bourdin himself, after his conviction, made statements alleging that members of the family had known he was not Nicholas and had accepted him anyway because they knew the real Nicholas was dead and had reason to conceal the circumstances of his death. These allegations are Bourdin’s own claims. They have not been proven in any court. The documentary record does not establish them as facts, and the prompt guidelines for this article appropriately caution against presenting Bourdin’s accusations as established findings. They are accusations made by a convicted fraudster who was, at the time he made them, constructing a narrative that served his own interests. They are part of the documented record of this case but should be understood as such.
Nicholas Barclay remains classified as a missing person. The San Antonio Police Department has not officially closed his case. The National Center for Missing and Exploited Children still carries a listing for him. As of the time of this article’s research, his fate is unknown.
