Cognitive and psychological research on motivated reasoning and wishful identification is relevant here. When people are strongly motivated to reach a particular conclusion, they process evidence differently than when they are in a neutral evaluation state. Beverly Dollarhide had been grieving her son for three years. The option that the person before her was her son was the option she desperately needed to be true. Research on false recognition and on the malleability of family member identification in long-term missing person cases has documented that this kind of motivated acceptance is not rare and does not indicate stupidity or willful blindness. It indicates that human cognition is influenced by emotional need.

The specific explanations Bourdin offered for the differences, the eye drop story, the forced French accent, the aging appearance, also deserve a moment of consideration. These explanations are, from the standpoint of a neutral outside observer, implausible. But the family was not neutral outside observers. And the story of a child held in captivity by traffickers and subjected to deliberate physical alteration was, in the late 1990s, the kind of narrative that received significant coverage in tabloid and true crime media. The cultural familiarity with captivity narratives may have made Bourdin’s explanations more available as an interpretive frame than they might be today.

None of this resolves the harder allegations: that Beverly or other family members may have known or suspected that the person in their home was not Nicholas and accepted him anyway because they knew the real Nicholas was dead. Those allegations remain unproven and legally unadjudicated. The evidence on the public record does not establish them.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.