By June 1994, Nicholas was facing a juvenile court hearing scheduled for the morning of June 14. Authorities had been considering placing him in a group home for troubled youth, an outcome Nicholas reportedly opposed strongly. The evening before that hearing, on June 13, 1994, Nicholas left home to play basketball with friends in the neighborhood. At some point during the evening, he called home asking someone to come and pick him up. His mother was asleep. His brother Jason refused to wake her, telling Nicholas to walk home on his own. Nicholas never arrived. When the family realized he had not come home, they assumed he had run away again, perhaps to avoid the court date. It would not be the first time he had disappeared for a short stretch. This time, he did not come back.
San Antonio police opened a missing persons report. Investigators looked into the possibility that Nicholas had run away voluntarily. The court hearing on June 14 came and went. Days passed without any sign of him. Weeks passed. The case remained open but generated few leads. Beverly entered drug rehabilitation after her son’s disappearance, and accounts from the period suggest the household changed substantially in his absence. Jason remained in the picture, and the family held out hope that Nicholas would eventually make contact.
In September 1994, roughly three months after Nicholas vanished, Jason told police he had spotted his brother late at night trying to break into the family garage. According to Jason’s account, Nicholas had appeared and then fled when he noticed he was being watched. Police investigated but found no trace of Nicholas in the area, no corroborating witnesses, and no physical evidence supporting the sighting. The family itself was divided on whether to believe Jason’s account. The case received no major updates for years. Nicholas Barclay remained listed as a missing person with the San Antonio Police Department, and also with the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children, the federally supported nonprofit organization that maintains records on missing and exploited children across the United States. His file sat in that system as 1994 passed into 1995, then into 1996, then into the first part of 1997.
