Beverly Dollarhide’s conflicting polygraph results do not establish anything legally, but they are part of the documented record of the investigation. Investigators were clearly exploring the possibility that the people closest to Nicholas at the time of his disappearance might have information they were not fully disclosing. That investigation did not produce criminal charges. It also did not definitively clear anyone.

The honest answer to the question of what happened to Nicholas Barclay is that no one outside of possibly one or two people knows, and no public evidence establishes the answer. He may have run away and died at some point in circumstances that were never connected to his identity. He may have been a victim of foul play unrelated to his family. He may have been a victim of circumstances within his family. The case is officially still open and officially unsolved.

—

## The Mechanics of the Impersonation: What Made It Possible

The Bourdin impersonation succeeded as long as it did because of a combination of factors that reflect systemic vulnerabilities rather than the gullibility of any single person.

The first factor was the information gap. In 1997, the electronic infrastructure for verifying identity across international borders was substantially less developed than it is today. Spanish authorities who processed Bourdin’s claim were working with a faxed photograph and a file from an American database. They did not have access to DNA records. They did not have easy access to biometric comparison tools. They had a person claiming to be an American boy, a documentation file from a credible source, and a family member who flew to Spain and signed papers saying yes, this is my brother.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.